If you are in Australia you would have to be deaf and blind not to have heard the baying of the wolves about foil ceiling insulation. You would think that the Government had personally snuck into the ceilings of unsuspecting citizens and installed incendiary bombs the way the media has represented it. This is a great example of a great product being killed by something outside the manufacturers control.
But lets start with the facts. The government of the day decided that one way to be conserve energy would be to subsidize the installation of ceiling insulation in houses in Australia. Home owners without insulation could do their research, get some quotes and then have insulation installed, the cost of which would be either fully or partially offset by the government. The scheme would create jobs through the manufacture and installation of insulation, reduce the load on the electricity grid and save consumers money – all at a time of economic crisis. Whatever your politics and whether or not you agree with the approach, this was the basis for the scheme.
At no time were citizens told which insulation they must buy or who should install it – people did their own research and made their own choices. They could choose from fibreglass batts, pumped in products, wool or foil – the choice was entirely theirs.
I was one of those many citizens who thought “You beauty” and decided to take the government up on its offer. So I hit the net. I checked out Choice – our consumer company to find out what insulation they recommended for our hot and humid Australian climate. Foil insulation came up trumps for Brisbane. I then hit the forums to hear other householders stories – looking for every possible flaw and mistake. Foil came out on top.It was clean (no dust allergens), helped repel moisture in case of a leaky roof (after our history with storms that was important), was stable, didn’t rot and worked extremely well. As a product it ticked every box.
I then scouted around for companies, looking for reputable installation companies that had been in business for a number of years. I quizzed the shortlisted companies to find out more about what made their company the one to choose, and then chose the best of the companies to install my foil roof insulation.
The company came when they said they would and everything went like clockwork. The insulation went in, I paid the extra money over and above the rebate (foil costs more than other forms of insulation) and the temperature inside the building dropped dramatically. “Ripper” I thought – this was great.
And then the stories started to emerge of people being electrocuted through insulation being installed with metal staples, and the staples hitting live electric wires. People died and the media started baying for blood.
But … between 1989 and 1992 3,627 Aussies died in workplace accidents. That’s over 900 a year or 2.5 people PER DAY in Australia die at work. There are so many workplace deaths that you can find death rates per industry – deaths per 100,000 employees reported as a regular statistic. And yet, these thousands of deaths per year go largely unreported. No one wants to ban products or try and bring down political parties for the 93 deaths per 100,000 forestry workers or 86 per 100 000 fishery employees. These people are almost seen as “disposable”. Nothing can be done. It is old news.
What happens when one of these people die at work? Well a Coronial inquest may be held. Investigations occur at the workplace. The company may be fined and the grieving wife (90% of all workplace deaths are men) is given some money to ease their suffering … in silence.
Look this is not a political tirade, but just a reflection on the facts. Yes, even one workplace death is one too many – a tragedy that needs to be learnt from. But let’s get some perspective here on the insulation issue.
Yes, there were cowboy installers that didn’t train their employees and as a result people died. The same can be said of many of the mining companies, fishing trawlers and other companies that have industrial deaths.
Yes, the scheme surrounding the installation could have been refined. Hindsight is always 100% accurate, and the public servants who designed the scheme did so with the best of intentions. They need to learn the lessons and refine the process for future schemes. But, remember, they are human and humans do make mistakes at times.
Is the Minister responsible. Under the Westminster scheme of politics – to be blunt yes. But then again so is the Minister for Mines for mining deaths, the Minister for Transport for truckie deaths and so on.
Foil ceiling insulation is essentially a good product, and yet now because of the media and political circus around it the product is tainted. There is nothing wrong with the product – just how it was used. And as a result it will be decades before the product can regain public confidence and in that time many foil roof insulation companies will go bust, with hundreds of employees put onto the street.
So what can business learn from the foil ceiling insulation debacle?
- If you are in business, does your disaster recovery plan take into account what would happen if your product suddenly becomes a political and media football? What would you do if your flagship product was suddenly so on the nose that people would pay you to take it away? These are the sorts of questions that each business owner and manufacturer needs to consider.
- Businesses need to realize that cutting corners on safety training is a dumb move. You are playing with people’s lives here. All staff need to be trained on basic safety requirements – and that includes casuals and temporary employees. No exceptions.
- Get a PR company on speed dial. Have you noticed that the only media coverage has been negative – where are the other viewpoints shoring up the product? Obviously no PR companies have been used by the foil companies (unlike the fibreglass batt companies I would suggest).
Until next time
Ingrid Cliff
We put your business into words
Heart Harmony – Freelance Copywriter
PS: Oh and yes, my roof is being inspected by a sparky tomorrow. Even with all my planning and analysis, safety comes first. I am not expecting any issues – after all there have been no sparking possums or fried snakes in my roof. But until the inspection, there will be no visits into the roof cavity to check.